Archive for the 'Personal' Category

The Lure of the Sea…

Tuesday, May 6th, 2008

Many thanks for chiming in with comments on yesterday. As with my mid-trip post, it is both surprising and touching to find out I was missed.

Yesterday I say I didn’t know where to start. But when it’s hard to know where to start, the easiest place to start is at the beginning, and where sailing is concerned my beginning is in Corona Del Mar, sometime in the late Seventies. My childhood best friend’s mother had remarried and I was just old enough to take the train up the coast to visit for a weekend during the Summer. The new husband (Ned) was a yachtsman. He had a big ketch, and my best friend (Jay) now spent his weekends sailing his sabot.

So that’s what we did on my first visit to Jay’s new home. We sailed his sabot all around Newport Harbor, and by the end of the weekend I understood the basics of how a sailboat worked. I was also hooked, completing the surfing, fishing, boating trifecta that has formed foundation my avocational life ever since.

Since the late Nineties I’ve been building boats, crafts ranging from a six foot pram for my daughter to a 25 foot sharpie schooner named after her, and I had been entertaining the fantasy of building a boat that we’d all be able to sail away on (and come back!)

But the economics of the last few years have been so weird that building big boats makes less and less sense. The cost of materials (wood, epoxy, paint, etc.) has skyrocketed. Meanwhile there’s a surfeit of well-found GRP boats from the Sixties and Seventies. (The ultimate useful life of glass reinforced plastic hulls is still unknown, but so far they appear to be nearly indestructible.)

This all came into focus late last Summer (I was outlining yet another design concept on my lawn with stakes and string.) I realized that the fantasy of building a boat was getting in the way of the fantasy of sailing away on a boat. I began looking at classified ads.

In October I found a boat that was sea-worthy, big enough, and within our budget (which is to say we’ve put off replacing our 1990 Volvo with a minivan for another few years.) It was in Georgia, so I flew down to look at it and spent about a week sailing it and living on it. In November we bought it, and in late December we drove from New York to Georgia, got on the boat and began our adventure.

We spent the next few weeks working our way down the coast of Florida. By late February we had (somehow) made it to Lake Worth, and the day after the full moon, we set out for our first (modest) open water passage; the jump across the Gulf Stream to the Abacos.

We made it and spent the next four weeks in the Abacos, then sailed back, running the 140 miles from Grand Keys to Port Canaveral in one long 32 hour stretch. With the benefit of our hard-won experience, we made the trip back to our car in Georgia in another six days. (Going the other way, getting from the car to Grand Keys had taken two months.)

Our trip was plagued by, perhaps even characterized by bad luck, bad weather, neophyte mistakes, doubt and uncertainty. The Southeast had one of its worst Winters in recent years, and it turns out that the Abacos is about the worst place you could choose to go on a boat in March (frontal passages, often violent, every 48-96 hours; very few all-weather anchorages; none of them deep enough for our boat to enter on low tide, if at all.)

Yes, sprinkled in amongst the drama and the trauma there were some wonderful moments, but mostly it was the most relentlessly grueling thing I’ve ever done, and I did it with my wife (who’s deathly afraid of water over her head,) my eight year old and two year old daughters, a very big dog and a small cat. It was never truly dangerous, but danger constantly lurked at the edges of our trip. Stress makes people make mistakes, we were under nearly constant stress, and mistakes on a boat can kill you.

Yet somehow we made it. Things were often bad, but not once did things go from bad to worse. My hydrophobic wife is the same person who shot the beautiful and award-winning “Ashley and Kisha” the very first time she raised a film camera to her eye. My wife is nothing if not resilient, adaptable, and able to rise to a challenge. Yesterday I wrote about falling asleep while the boat made way under a starry sky; well that was on our run back across the Gulf Stream to Port Canaveral, and Peggy was at the helm.

My girls drove back from Georgia. I posted a noticed to a boat-building list that I needed crew, and four weeks later we were all together again, 1000 miles from where we first got on the boat. Who knows what our two year old thought of the trip, but our eight year old thought it was wonderful, says she’d do it again in an instant. (Has she already forgotten how scared she was when the last front that we endured started spinning off water-spouts at a rate of about one a minute, or just come to an early understanding that life is a rich stew of varied experiences? Or maybe sitting on the bow while dolphins splashed and lept was that good.)

Yesterday afternoon she and I went out to boat for study-hall (she is bedeviled by the same inane reading comprehension assignments that tormented me when I was in the third grade.) The weather’s just nice enough to be on the boat (with a sweater) but it’s still too early to be in the water. But those days will here soon enough, and they’ll be no insipid reading comprehension homework to muck it up.

I’m home, and it’s good to be home.

Home is where the heart is. (There’s no place like home!)

Sunday, May 4th, 2008

I am back home.

Peggy and the girls got home last month (they got off the boat in Georgia,) and I just finished the month-long task of bringing our boat up the Eastern Seaboard. I got home three days ago. I’ve been doing laundry, mowing the lawn, sleeping, and reading my friends’ and colleagues’ blogs to get up to speed on everything that’s been going on during my four month hiatus, and it looks like there are a lot of exciting projects cooking — books, collumns, art-spaces, new films — all sorts of things!

Would you like to know about our trip? I’d like to tell you, but it’s hard to know where to start, except that long before I ever had any aspiration to make films, I dreamed of sailing a boat out of sight of land, through the night, and on to someplace with warm clear water.  I can now say, with more than a little satisfaction, that I’ve fallen asleep on deck while the boat made way under a star-filled sky, and I’ve played with my children in water as clear and warm as any five-star hotel’s pool. Some days were heaven, some were indescribably hard; little, if any of it, was anything like a vacation.  But in the sum and total the trip was one of the most worthwhile things I’ve ever done.

Against that, I am, for the moment, enjoying the fantasy that making films and getting them seen is going to feel easy by comparison to what we’ve just done. But of course they are different adventures, each with their own frustrations and satisfactions. But maybe (just maybe) I’ll find that I have a little more perspective on the film ‘ting. No matter how frustrating (or financially damaging) it may be to have a film banned, or passed over by a festival, neither poses a risk to life or limb.

So, back to the edit bay, and “Bill and Desiree”. Back to blogging. Back to newsletters and press releases. Back to all of the things that are my (so called) real life. And it’s good to be back. It’s good to be home.

Not Dead (Yet)

Thursday, March 13th, 2008


Hard on the wind, somewhere in the Gulf Stream

First: an apology. I didn’t mean to disappear without a trace; and it really didn’t occur to me that anyone would notice, let alone worry.

Second: thank you, thank you, thank you! Thank you to my friends who wrote me when our Web site went offline. Thank you to my friends who wrote to say , “Is everything okay?” And thank you to my friends who wrote to say, “Hey, I miss you.”

Everything is fine. Peggy and I are spending some long overdue time with our children, having one of those family adventures that has been as much hard work as it has been adventurous fun. (Yesterday we sailed through a 40kts+ squall, with blinding rain so fierce it blocked our GPS signal for 15 minutes. Thank goodness for compasses and the rock solid reliability of the Earth’s magnetic field!)

I thought I might get some work done on this trip. Ha! If you think it’s hard to find time to edit while managing the marketing and promotion of a small film production company, try going sailing with two young children, a dog and a cat! So for those of you who have asked, no, there isn’t another film on the eve of release.

But, we’ll be back home before too much longer, and I’ve learned one thing that will (hopefully) help me get the next film finished. These films are good enough that they keep selling, even without me flogging them relentlessly. Hopefully that will help keep me from worrying that this will all come crashing down around me while I’m spending time in the edit bay instead of blogging, writing press releases, and generally blowing my own horn.

Speaking of blowing my own horn, some exciting news. Both DAMON AND HUNTER and ASHLEY AND KISHA will be a part of this year’s Israel International LGBT Film Festival, taking place June 24-28 in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, and Haifa. And this morning we got a request to submit a screener of ASHLEY AND KISHA to New York’s Newfest. No, I won’t be going to Israel, so cross your fingers for Newfest. I’d really like to see ASHLEY AND KISHA play in front of an audience!

Now I’ve got to use the rest of my internet time to see if I can find an “Idiot’s Guide to Tapping Aluminum.” The boat’s boom and gooseneck are trying to part ways, and there’s still 500 miles between us and where we left our car…

Goodbye to An Old Friend

Friday, August 31st, 2007

Winter 2002 was not a happy time here at Casa Comstock. Two years earlier the dot com bubble had burst, cutting Peggy’s web design business by 75%. Over the next year, a couple of solid commissions for my documentary work kept us more or or less even, but after 9/11, the phone went silent. I took advantage of the quite that Autumn and edited MARIE AND JACK: A HARDCORE LOVE STORY, which had been shot earlier that year.

By February 2002 thing were dire. M&J had been finished for five months, but was going no where fast. We hadn’t renewed the lease on our midtown office, but trying to hang tough in the six months of the lease after 9/11 had drained our savings. To make end meet our apartment in New York was sublet, but our house is too long a commute to pick up day work in the city. I checked eBay daily and watch the value of my AVID go down down down while it sat idle. Finally, at the end of February I sold my AVID – the cpu, the card, the RAID, the two 20 inch monitors – for $4,000, less than 10% of what I bought it for a few years earlier. I was officially dead in the water.

But I did have a plan.

If by some miracle I got my teeth into a job, I figured I’d by a Macintosh and a copy of FinalCutPro, Apple’s new, hardware independent, “AVID for the masses.” By hook or by crook I’d use FCP to cut the job. With whatever was left over I’d figure out what to do next.

Six long weeks later, my miracle came.

It came in the form of a commision to produce a documentary about a small slice of the 9/11 recovery effort. We shot it on the same two Sony PD100a cameras that were used to shoot MARIE AND JACK, and it was the first film I edited using FinalCutPro on a powerbook.

The Powerbook/FCP combo proved surprisingly capable. I ended up editing and finishing a couple more commissioned pieces, as well as XANA AND DAX: WHEN OPPOSITES ATTRACT on the same machine. (DAMON AND HUNTER was also edited on that machine, but was finished on a more powerful edit station, capable of working with uncompressed HD footage.) The powerbook became my e-mail and web machine. All the ranting and raving you read here, as well as any unhinged e-mails any of you may have received were typed on that machine.

All but this post I’m typing right now.

Half a year ago, my second daughter, just learn to walk, tried to kill my trusty 400mHz powerbook when she careened into it as I sat with her watching MAZY MOUSE and reading blogs. She didn’t kill the machine outright, but she did bust the hinges. I’ve been restricted to ranting at my desk, screen propped up against my NTSC studio monitor since then.

But tonight the powerbook met its end. Again my younger daughter was the culprit.

While I was ranting on the phone to Tony Hey at the MPAA (he’s the finest kind of old movie buff, and we were talking about war movies,) she climbed my office chair and tried to get at my razor phones that try to keep out her reach on top of the NTSC monitor.

Leaning as far as she could (the chair was away from the desk) she capsized the chair, with my old faithful powerbook in the fall line. Down came the computer, down came my daughter, down came one of the phones too. The crippled screen was ripped from the keyboard, wires and all.

My daughter is fine. My phone is fine. But my old friend, the powerbook that saved my family from dying in the cold is done. It’s in two pieces that will never again be one.

Just last week Peggy got a new MacBook to replace her toddler damaged 400mhz Powerbook. I took the drive out of my dead machine and now it’s in Peggy’s old machine. The hinges on this machine are fine, but somethings wrong with the screen. When the machine heats up, the picture breaks up, and that’s what’s happening now as I finish the eulogy to my old friend. I can barely see what I’m typing, which I guess means this rant is over.

Row, Row, Row Your Boat, Part 2

Tuesday, June 19th, 2007

The oars are coming along nicely. Did some sanding on Monday, but mostly I sat in front of the computer, fretting about when the Oprah thing was going to come out, until my daughter’s classmate’s father called and asked if my daughter and I wanted to go sailing. That was much better than sitting and fretting. Not too long after I got home, Violet posted her pictures, which was exciting.

This morning I went down to the drugstore, put in my wife’s prescription for birth-control and bought two copies of the July issue of O. Then I walked across the way to the hardware store and got a quart of varnish. The humidity was high today, so even though I put the varnish on before noon, it was still tacky last I checked. I also did some work on the boats (pictured below) that these oars are for. The one on the left needs its shear-clamp replaced, (you can see the sticks for that task in the boat.) Both need new cleats for the oarlock sockets, and a fresh coat of paint.

Other than a Fleshbot mention and Violet’s post, and of course holding the magazine in my hand, you’d wouldn’t know the Oprah thing had happened. No sudden dramatic increase in traffic, no sudden flood of sales. After mentions in Time, Esquire, Penthouse, Jane, and few others, I’ve learned not to expect such things, but it doesn’t stop me from daydreaming! ;-)

Row, Row, Row Your Boat…

Sunday, June 17th, 2007

In a comment on the recent ASHLEY AND KISHA Ships! post the Always Aroused Girl asked, “Do you do nothing but watch people fuck?”

As it happens, she asked this question while I has enjoying my first Saturday off in over five years.

What I mean by that is this weekend is the first weekend since the Spring of 2002 that I have not owed someone a movie. In those five years I have produced the five erotic documentaries offered here, two commissioned docs (one on 9/11 and one on grass-roots relief work,) and one self-produced short doc about the indigenous fishery on Lake Victoria.

I tend to think of my self as a lazy(ish) person. I tend to think of myself as a person who wastes a lot of time worrying about things instead of doing things about things (because it’s true.)

But when I contemplate the fact that in the last five years I’ve produced, directed, and edited eight films, each well received, with a total running time of about 275 minutes–well my goodness, that’s something, isn’t it? Add to that creating, from the ground up, a distribution system for films that were (until we did it) regarded as “undistributable”, we’ll that seems like a bit of an accomplishment, doesn’t it.

Yesterday, on my first Saturday off in five years I went to the lumber yard and got a couple of planks and made them into a pair of oars. The boats I made them for need a little patching up before they’ll be ready for an outing. I might do that today. I might do it on Monday. The boss has given me the day off! ;-)

You think it’s tough talking to your kids about sex? Try talking to them about torture.

Thursday, May 17th, 2007

I endeavor to avoid writing about politics on this blog, except when politics intersect with sex. I avoid politics because I don’t want how I feel about deficit spending, or gun control, or NAFTA or other rancorous issues to become entangled in how people understand my films. So much at I might be tempted to vent, I don’t. Not usually.

Some background.

Peggy and I have two children, two daughters, one seven and a half, the other not yet two. Before I became a parent, the guiding star for my work was that I did not want to do anything I would be embarrassed or ashamed to show to my mother. After I became a parent I stopped looking back and started looking forward. My daughter became my new star, and my new guidance was that I did not want to do anything that I would be embarrassed or ashamed to explain, when the time came, to my daughter. What we tell our older daughter about our work is calibrated to what she knows about sex.

She knows about reproduction, and is fascinated by the workings of genetics (I am a recessive blue dark-eyed person, Peggy has fair eyes. There have been many discussions Mendelian principals.) She knows the proper names of her sex organs so far as she’s asked, which is to say that she knows her vagina is different from her vulva. She knows the name of my sex organs too. She knows that her mother’s body is different from hers, and that when she is older, she will get breasts and pubic hair, and her body will change from being a straight-sided child’s body to a more or less curvy woman’s body. She knows about menstruation.

I also know that she knows that people who love each other enjoy being close to each other, and I think she understands that although there are many similarities in the way that she snuggles with me or her mother, there is also something different in the way that Peggy and I snuggle, that it means something different when mommy and daddy snuggle. She knows about eggs and sperm, and how babies grow in their mother’s tummies. She knows that babies emerge from their mothers’ vaginas. She has yet to ask just how the sperm gets into mommy’s tummy. When that day comes, I’m not sure what I’m going to tell her, except that whatever it is, it is going to be the truth.

Against this understanding of her knowledge, we tell her that we make films about the good feeling that it gives people to be close to someone they love, and the good feeling it gives people to hear stories about that good feeling and see people who are in love.

Back to politics.

A couple of months ago, on the way to drop my daughter off at school, she asked me about the war in Iraq. I did my best to explain in simple, objective facts, without betraying my own bias. I thought I was doing pretty well until she asked me, “Who started it?”

I felt myself freeze for a moment, then I said, “We did, honey.”

“We did?” bewilderment running across her face. “Why?”

We had arrived at school and I was let off the hook. “If you want, we can talk about this some more after school,” and politics did not come up again, until last night. Last night our daughter asked me why people are saying we torture people.

“Why are people saying we torture people?” How do you answer that question? How do you calibrate your answer against what you think your child knows about stress positions and water-boarding and the Geneva Convention and the blast radius of a suitcase nuke? After a bit of hesitation, I told her, as simply and gently as I could, what I believe to be the truth.

There is a lot of worrying in our country about what happens if children are exposed to sexual ideas or sexual imagery before they are ready to understand it. I think these concerns have merit, but I also think part of my responsibility as a parent is to give my children the knowledge they need to, as best they can, understand and incorporate sexuality as a part of the human experience and as a part of their own experience. To my mind, this is the best prophylactic against their inappropriate exposure to sex, and to mitigate whatever ill effects it might have. It’s hard to know if you’re doing too much, or not doing enough, but Peggy and I bumble along as best we can.

But as ill prepared as I might feel about being my daughter’s guide on her journey from a child’s understanding and experience of sex to that of an adult, I am far far less prepared to be her guide in a world where her own government subjects prisoners to water-boarding and other “enhanced interrogation techniques.” When I was her age, I was indoctrinated in the idea that we simply didn’t do things like this in America, and that’s what made us different and better than our mortal adversary, the Soviet Union. I was taught this difference was something worth making sacrifices for, worth killing for, even worth dying for if need be. I was indoctrinated in these ideals and I still believe in them. I don’t know how to explain torture to my daughter without becoming confused and angry. Compared to explaining torture, explaining why mommy and daddy make dirty movies seems like a walk in the park.

Perhaps some of you think I’m naive, and perhaps you even disagree with me. If so, I hope you will chalk it up to the same idealism that has sustained our efforts to make our films, and excuse this outburst as the ranting of an overwrought parent who only wants the best for his children, and wants them to grow up in a country that is regarded throughtout the world as a place that is different and special.

Torture, as defined in the US Legal Code

It’s Our Cage, Too
Torture Betrays Us and Breeds New Enemies
By Charles C. Krulak (commandant of the Marine Corps from 1995 to 1999) and Joseph P. Hoar (commander in chief of U.S. Central Command from 1991 to 1994)

Verschärfte Vernehmung (Enhanced Interrogation)

Thanks for 10 Amazing Years

Wednesday, January 3rd, 2007

Ten years ago today, Peggy and I walked from our apartment to Times Square, got on the R train. We got off at the City Hall station, and I bet you can guess what happened next.

I don’t think that Peggy ever could have guessed what she was signing on for that day and when I think about all that has happened between that day and this, I actually feel a little dizzy. I’m incredibly proud of what Peggy and I have accomplished in the last 10 years, but I sometimes wonder if our lives wouldn’t be easier without this Comstock Films nonsense. Things like this recent Google dust-up are stressfull, and that stress takes its toll. I sometimes worry about what I’ve put her through, what I’ve asked her to give up, so that I can make these films.

But in all these ten years, she’s never asked me to stop. And when I’ve despaired, she’s the one who reminds me how important this work is to me. She’s the one who takes out the thank you letters from viewers and reminds me that it’s important to other people too.

Thank you Peggy, for saying “yes” when I asked you to be my wife. Thank you for going through with it and marrying me, then sticking with through thick and thin. I can’t imagine what the last ten years would have been like without you.

Happy tenth anniversary, honey. I love you more than ever!

It’s Not About Procreation.

Tuesday, May 9th, 2006

“It’s not about procreation. It’ll never be about procreation. Neither one of us is getting pregnant anytime soon. So we have to be a little more honest. This is about pleasure, this about getting off, and doing it together.” — Damon Demarco, from Damon and Hunter: Doing it Together

Duh. We get it Tony. Damon and Hunter are gay.

Among the various outrages I’ve been accused of, subtlety is not one of them. I’m a ham-fisted sentimentalist, and proud of it. But today’s blog post “The War on Contraception is a War on Sex” on Violet Blue’s TinyNibbles.com has helped me finally the words to my own personal subtext to the opening of D&H.

I am a breeder. Not just a breeder, but a breeder who has bred. More than once I have impregnated my wife, and then watch as her belly grew larger and larger, until they day when finally it could grow no more, and a baby, a new life emerged from her body, driving her nearly mad with hours of agonizing pain in the process. I treasure my children, and regard them as the greatest among many gifts my union with my wife has brought me. I know as well as anyone else that conceiving children can be one of the great joys of having sex.

But I deeply resent the suggestion, the assertion that by taking steps to avoid an unplanned pregnancy, or engaging in intimate acts that could never result in pregnancy that we have somehow degraded our love for one another, or debased the intimate time we spend together. I resent it when someone says that about my wearing a condom or my wife using contraceptives, and I resent it when someone says that about two men loving one another or two women loving one another. However it’s said, it’s an outright assault on the most precious, personal aspect of the relationship between me and my wife.

I didn’t demand my wife prove her fertility before we were wed, nor did she ask the same of me. We became lovers, and then became husband and wife in large measure because of the sexual desire we felt for one another. And I deeply resent the assertion that the way I feel about my wife – the need for her I feel, the hunger for her I feel, the way I adore looking at her naked body and the way that fills me with desire – can only be justified by the possibility of conception.

I love our children. I am profoundly moved by the knowledge that their fleshly existence is a product of my and my wife’s fleshy union; and I cannot imagine my life with out them. But our children do not sanctify our marriage, they do not consecrate our lovemaking. They do not excuse the carnal desire I feel for my wife, or the pleasure I take from reveling in her flesh. And I wonder just what goes on inside the mind of a person who would seek to heap these unwarranted burdens of justification, consecration and excuse upon my children or their own. It seems cruel and sad and perverse to insist any child must carry such burdens.

And fortunately ours do not.

Because it’s not about procreation for us either. Not all the time. Not even most of the time. It’s about pleasure; my pleasure, my wife’s pleasure. It’s about getting off – and doing it together!

Does anyone know where the love of God goes…

Saturday, May 6th, 2006

When I was a small child, in the Summer when the hot Santa Ana winds would blow the sea flat, my mother would take me down to the beach and she’d swim me out to look down through the clear water at the fish. I still remember how much I dreaded the sting of the windblown sand, and how much more I loved clinging to her back as she swam away from the beach; and seeing the leopard sharks, shovel nosed guitar fish, and schools of silvery green grunion.

A few years later, I started to learn to fish from my grandfather, and to surf from his son. I learned to row and to sail. When I was about ten I read The Boy who Sailed Around the World Alone, and began to dream about making journeys past the horizon and learned to navigate out of sight of land.

I still love to surf and sail and fish, and the last several years I’ve even taught myself a little carpentry and built a few simple boats. I love the beach and the ocean, and all things maritime. Partly because of this, Peggy and I are engrossed in another season of The Deadliest Catch, a Discovery Channel serial documentary.

The first season chronicled the last Alaskan King crab derby, a system of fisheries management that compels boats and their crews to work almost non-stop for days on end, in an effort to catch as much of the fleet’s total quota as they can. In the first season of the show, The Big Valley (a boat that did not have a camera crew on it) sank in the hours before the opening of Opie season, with the loss of five of her six crewmen. An investigation suggests the Big Valley was carrying more crab pots on deck than she was rated for, and that this was a key factor in her sinking.

This second season of the show is the first year of a per-boat quota system. Based on their previous years’ catches, the Alaskan Department of Fisheries allocated each boat in the fleet a portion of the total quota. The thought is that having a guaranteed portion of the catch will encourage captains and crews to be more measured in their calculus of risk and returns. Compared to the first season, the pace of the fishing in this second season of the show seems to have been slower and safer.

But this season the weather’s been worse. In a fierce storm during red crab season, one boat was hit broadside by an immense rogue wave that put her on beam ends. She came back to her feet, but both engines had shut down. For long minutes she was helpless in the face of the storm while her crew raced to restart the engines and regain control of the boat, all while the Discovery Channel’s camera rolls. The end of the derby system has lowered the incentive to fish as hard, or in the most marginal conditions, but it hasn’t tamed the sea.

The same year I got my first sailboat, the laker the Edmund Fitzgerald, an ore carrier over 700 feet long was lost with all hands in a late Autumn storm on Lake Superior. For someone who grew up on the ocean, it’s hard for me to imagine that conditions on an inland lake could ever become so severe that a 700 foot ship could disappear suddenly and without warning, yet it happened.

Of the several theories surrounding the sinking of the Fitzgerald, one is that when she lost her radar earlier in the storm made it impossible for her navigator determine their position with sufficient accuracy to avoid the Six Fathom Shoal north of Caribou Island, and that in the violence of the storm she scraped bottom and began to take water, which ultimately combined with the heavy seas to deadly effect.

So much has changed since then, making navigation easier, and boating safer. GPS can tell you your position within feet, anywhere in the word, and it’s inexpensive. I routinely carry a waterproof GPS and waterproof VHF radio, even when just rowing a few hundred yards off shore to fish. If I somehow ended up in the water or lost an oar and started to blow out to sea, I could could determine my position within feet, day or night, whatever the conditions, and call for help. Total cost for both units, less than $200. How different from the Fitzgerald. At night, in a fierce storm, their radar carried off by the wind, they were utterly blind; and the lake had become as vast and unforgiving as any ocean.

There’s no way to know if modern technology would have saved the crew of Edmund Fitzgerald. Some theories place the blame squarely on the crew’s failure to properly secure her cargo hatches, and that the gradual accumulation of water combined with the unexpectedly bad conditions to cause a sudden, catastrophic loss of buoyancy. At sea, like anywhere else, casual negligence kills more people that pure bad luck.

Where ever the blame lies, whether on the Big Valley or the Fitzgerald, it doesn’t lessen the shock or the sorrow.

“Does any one know where the love of God goes when the waves turn the minutes to hours?
And all that remains are the faces and the names of the wives and the sons and the daughters.”